Michigan House Bill HB4093

Michigan 2025-2026 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/19/25
• Refer: 2/19/25

Caption

Courts: juries; reference in the uniform condemnation procedures act; amend to reflect repeal. Amends sec. 12 of 1980 PA 87 (MCL 213.62). TIE BAR WITH: HB 4091'25

Impact

The proposed changes introduce a requirement for a separate trial concerning just compensation for each parcel of property involved, barring any demonstration of good cause to consolidate trials. This amendment could significantly affect the legal landscape surrounding property disputes in condemnation cases, emphasizing the right to a jury's involvement in compensation assessment, which may lead to increased legal costs and logistical challenges in property condemnation proceedings.

Summary

House Bill 4093 aims to amend the Uniform Condemnation Procedures Act (1980 PA 87) in Michigan to clarify the process regarding jury trials for just compensation. It explicitly states that either a plaintiff or a defendant can demand a jury trial on the issue of just compensation, as governed by applicable laws and court rules. The bill stipulates that the jury will comprise six qualified electors, ensuring adherence to the judicial protocols outlined within the Michigan Compiled Laws.

Contention

The bill's tie bar with HB 4091 implies that its enactment is dependent on the passage of another legislative measure, which may introduce additional layers of complexity and potential contention. The need for separate trials for each parcel could be viewed as a double-edged sword; while it enhances the legal protection of property owners, it may also provoke frustration among governmental agencies and businesses seeking swift resolutions to property acquisition, potentially prolonging the condemnation process.