New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York Senate Bill S08515

Introduced
9/26/25  
Refer
9/26/25  

Caption

Enacts the "consumer utility meter choice protection act"; allows customers to decline the installation of smart meters without being liable for fees.

Impact

If enacted, S08515 would significantly amend existing provisions of the public service law by establishing clear rights for consumers. Utilities would be required to notify customers at least ninety days prior to the installation of a two-way smart meter, and customers would have 365 days following installation to request removal without additional charges. This shift seeks to ensure consumer choice is prioritized, potentially altering how utility companies engage with their customers and manage their metering systems.

Summary

Bill S08515, titled the 'Consumer Utility Meter Choice Protection Act', aims to provide customers of electric, gas, and water service utilities the right to decline the installation of smart meters without incurring any fees or penalties. This legislation arises from growing concerns regarding the mandatory adoption of advanced metering infrastructure, specifically two-way smart meters, which utilize state-of-the-art communication technologies to provide real-time usage data. The bill emphasizes customer autonomy in choosing whether such devices are installed at their premises, thereby enhancing consumer protections under the public service law.

Contention

There are notable points of contention surrounding the bill, particularly regarding the balance between technological advancements in utility management and consumer freedom. Proponents argue that smart meters can offer significant efficiencies and cost savings for both utilities and consumers; however, opponents express concerns that mandatory installations encroach on individual rights and freedoms. Questions surrounding data privacy, cybersecurity, and the obligations of utilities to upgrade their infrastructure could further complicate discussions among stakeholders as the bill moves through the legislative process.

Companion Bills

NY A03978

Same As Enacts the "consumer utility meter choice protection act"; allows customers to decline the installation of smart meters without being liable for fees.

Previously Filed As

NY A03978

Enacts the "consumer utility meter choice protection act"; allows customers to decline the installation of smart meters without being liable for fees.

NY HB1038

Smart meters; provide utility customers with option to decline installation of.

NY A11138

Enacts the "smart meter transparency and consumer protection act" in relation to requiring utilities to provide certain information about smart meters to customers; authorizes and directs the public service commission, in coordination with an independent third party, to conduct a study on smart meter implementation in New York state.

NY S1936

Provides electric public utility customers' right to decline installation of smart meter under certain circumstances.

NY A891

Provides electric public utility customers' right to decline installation of smart meter under certain circumstances.

NY HB1217

Require customer consent for installation of a smart meter for a utility service.

NY A671

Requires electric public utility to install and operate smart meters and smart meter technology at customers' premises upon request and in new building construction.

NY H3551

Relative to smart meters

NY S2306

Relative to smart meters

NY S08530

Enacts the utility transparency and fair billing protection act to prevent consumers from being overcharged due to misclassified utility rates by mandating proactive account reviews, automatic adjustments, and ensuring clear communication between utilities and customers.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.