Prohibits the sale of a court transcript by any person other than a stenographer.
Impact
Should A10298 be enacted, it will have a significant impact on existing laws regarding the management and distribution of court transcripts. Primarily, the bill will reinforce the exclusivity of stenographers in handling the reproduction of transcripts, thus safeguarding the standard of transcription services within New York's legal framework. This could also lead to a more streamlined process for parties seeking to obtain certified transcripts, as they would know precisely who is authorized to provide these documents.
Summary
Bill A10298 aims to amend the judiciary law by prohibiting any court, party, or person, other than a stenographer, from providing or selling a court transcript to a third party. This legislation seeks to regulate the transcription industry by ensuring that only authorized stenographers are allowed to furnish these important records. The bill's introduction underlines its intent to protect the integrity of court documents and ensure that consumers receive accurate and reliable transcripts from certified professionals.
Contention
Despite its intent to regulate the transcription process, A10298 might face scrutiny regarding the balance of power between courts, parties, and legal service providers. Some stakeholders may argue that restricting the sale of transcripts to only stenographers could limit access to these records for individuals and entities that seek them for legitimate purposes. Critics may raise concerns about potential monopolistic practices, as this bill may prevent alternative transcription services from entering the market, ultimately leading to higher costs for those needing access to court documents.
Prohibits transcripts being made from video conference meetings by artificial intelligence without conspicuous disclosure during such meeting that such meeting may be transcribed by artificial intelligence.